Publisher Subscription Strategies in the AI Era

As AI-generated answers increasingly keep users on search platforms and within answer engines, publishers are already seeing fewer readers click through to their sites. Google traffic from organic search to more than 2,500 sites was down by a third globally last year, according to Chartbeat data cited in the Journalism and Technology Trends and Predictions 2026 report by the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism. Fewer opportunities to reach new audiences make it harder to acquire subscribers — and make the value of existing subscribers soar.

As of March 2026, 36.1% of Google searches included an AI Overview, according to Comscore. That was up from 30.2% in October 2025 and 23.4% in May 2025, underscoring how quickly AI-generated answers are becoming part of the traditional search experience.

“The audience publishers once monetized is disappearing from view,” said Andrew Quicho, industry marketing lead at Braze. “Google’s AI Overviews now reach billions of monthly users, and their presence also correlates with a lower click-through rate for top-ranked pages in search results. This isn’t a new threat. It’s the SEO erosion publishers have watched for a decade reaching new heights as readers get answers without visiting a publisher’s real estate. The audience publishers can still see, own and grow is the one that has opted in by logging in, registering or subscribing.”

That shift is putting greater pressure on publishers to acquire subscribers, retain them and make better use of the audience data they collect. It is also pushing publishers to rethink engagement, content formats and potential revenue opportunities as AI changes how readers discover information.

“If AI reduces the frequency with which users visit publisher websites directly, building strong and lasting customer relationships becomes even more important,” said Alexander Thrum, head of customer retention at Bild, a daily German newspaper published by Axel Springer. “Our focus is therefore increasingly on creating direct connections with readers through subscriptions, newsletters, registered user experiences, personalization and ongoing engagement.” 

In this new State of the Industry report, Digiday and Braze surveyed 90 publishers in August 2026 to learn how they are adapting their subscription, engagement and revenue strategies in response to AI search, including how they are using data, fostering reader relationships and preparing for the future of publishing. The survey also surfaced a gap between the data publishers prioritize and the audience relationships their strategies depend on.

As surveyed publishers navigate the effects of AI search, the majority are eager to expand their subscriber base. Sixty percent of survey respondents said acquiring new subscribers is the main focus of their company’s subscription strategy, while 40% said retaining current subscribers is their top priority.

The emphasis on acquisition reflects publishers’ need to grow their recurring revenue base as AI-driven search makes traditional referral traffic less predictable. A robust subscriber base also gives publishers the opportunity to build more sustainable direct relationships, especially as retaining subscribers becomes increasingly important.

“Our strategic focus is actually balanced between both areas,” Bild’s Thrum said. “We have dedicated teams for acquisition and retention. For that reason, we view both streams as equally important and as essential pillars of our subscription business. Sustainable growth requires both successful acquisition and strong retention.”

Bild’s parent company Axel Springer recently bet on the value of a loyal subscriber base with its acquisition of the U.K.-based Telegraph Media Group, which had a total of 1.16 million subscriptions at the end of 2025, according to A Media Operator. Axel Springer operates in more than 25 countries, with media brands including Politico, Business Insider and Morning Brew.

“The Telegraph is particularly interesting because it brings a large and well-established subscriber base, as well as significant experience in building a successful digital subscription business,” Thrum said. “Looking ahead, I believe one of the biggest opportunities will be the exchange of knowledge and best practices across the different publishing brands within Axel Springer. This is especially relevant in areas such as subscriber acquisition, customer retention, engagement and subscription growth.”

When Digiday and Braze asked publishers what tactics they are using to attract new subscribers amid AI search, they were most focused on offering promotional discounts and member-exclusive content. Surveyed publishers’ top five means to acquire new subscribers were promotional discounts for subscriptions (89%), member-exclusive newsletters (80%), member-exclusive research or data access (77%), member-exclusive podcasts (53%) and member-exclusive articles (47%).

Similarly, surveyed publishers’ top five historically best-performing means of acquisition were promotional discounts for subscriptions (84%), member-exclusive research or data access (74%), member-exclusive newsletters (73%), member-exclusive podcasts (57%) and member-exclusive articles (43%).

The prominence of discounts in publishers’ acquisition strategies reflects how strongly they are prioritizing subscriber growth and how challenging subscriber acquisition has become, especially as they begin to reach a ceiling in their ability to grow subscriber bases from existing audiences. 

“Historically, pricing campaigns have been one of the strongest acquisition drivers, as attractive introductory offers encourage users to experience the value of our products,” Thrum said. “At the same time, a significant number of new subscribers still come through our journalism itself. Ultimately, the most successful strategy is the combination of compelling journalism, attractive subscriber benefits and well-targeted acquisition campaigns.”

A second-quarter 2025 analysis of 86 news brands by Mather Economics and the International News Media Association found that every publisher included in the study had offered new subscribers discounts of 90% or more at some point during the previous year. Publishers in the study differed in how long those discounts remained in place and the step-up pricing applied at renewal.

 As a whole, these statistics reveal a fundamental paradox in subscription strategies: acquisition often comes at the expense of immediate, full-price subscription revenue, which makes long-term audience retention critical. Yet 60% of survey respondents said acquiring new subscribers is the main focus of their subscription strategy, compared with 40% who said retaining current subscribers is the top priority.

The economics of discount acquisition strategies make retention increasingly critical, according to Quicho. “Paywall conversion, post-trial retention, and re-engagement are no longer just growth metrics,” Quicho said. “They’ve evolved into becoming survival metrics. A publisher that improves retention makes every acquisition dollar compound.”

Beyond discounts, publishers are also using exclusive content to give prospective audiences a reason to become paying subscribers as search referrals decline. Bloomberg, The Wall Street Journal and Fortune have rolled out paywalled video series and livestreams in an effort to convert younger, high-intent readers. These publishers are pulling more of their premium formats back onto their own sites and apps rather than leaving their most valuable content on YouTube and social platforms.

The Economist has similarly expanded beyond its traditional article-based subscription with Economist Play, a lower-priced tier for its audio and video journalism aimed at younger and more diverse audiences. The standalone product bundles its long-form Insider video shows, paywalled podcasts, daily audio briefings, short-form videos, subscriber-only newsletters and games, giving consumers who are more likely to listen and watch than read another way to engage with the publisher.

“The shift is from waiting for repeat organic visits to getting users registered during the first session,” Quicho said. “Publishers can no longer assume readers will return through search often enough to convert on the publisher’s timeline. Capture, preference gathering and onboarding now need to begin at the first touch and not after several visits.”

Quicho added that treating search as a renewable top-of-funnel channel that can always be replenished no longer works. “Strategies built on the assumption of recurring organic reach are the first to break,” he said.

When Digiday and Braze asked publishers what means they are currently using to retain subscribers amid AI search, their retention tactics mostly aligned with their acquisition strategies, with the exception of promotional discounts.

Surveyed publishers said their top five offerings to retain subscribers were member-exclusive newsletters (86%), member-exclusive research or data access (80%), personalized content (66%), member-exclusive podcasts (60%) and member-exclusive articles (40%).

Similarly, surveyed publishers’ top five historically best-performing offerings to retain subscribers were member-exclusive research or data access (81%), member-exclusive newsletters (80%), member-exclusive podcasts (61%), personalized content (61%) and member-exclusive articles (38%).

Taken together, these responses suggest that surveyed publishers consider exclusive content and products as central to their subscriber retention strategies. Newsletters, research and data, podcasts and articles give subscribers deeper content benefits they cannot access as non-paying readers, while personalized content offers another way to reinforce an experience that would be less rich and tailored without a subscription. The close alignment of the offerings surveyed publishers currently use most with those they say have historically performed best indicates that surveyed publishers are well aware that the best way to keep subscribers happy is to offer a strong product. 

“A key focus is continuously communicating the value of the subscription through exclusive benefits such as subscriber-only newsletters, competitions, app features and premium content,” Bild’s Thrum explained. “We also use engagement measures to encourage regular interaction with our products and strengthen long-term loyalty.”

Bild uses niche emails like “Klatsch To Go” and customized newsletters to channel traffic back to its BildPlus subscription portal. Other publishers’ subscriber-exclusive newsletters range from The Verge’s technology and politics newsletter “Regulator” to The Wall Street Journal’s business and market summaries. Bloomberg’s distinctive strategy includes premium newsletters that are part of its regular news subscription along with a newsletter-only subscription focused on technology, according to Digiday+ Research’s 2025 Subscription Index.

Targeted retention offers for customers who have cancelled subscriptions before the subscriptions expired are also critical, according to Thrum. “Historically, pricing incentives have been one of the most effective tools for preventing churn, as customers are currently very price-sensitive when it comes to subscriptions,” Thrum said. “Overall, our retention strategy combines engagement, value communication, exclusive benefits and targeted retention offers.”

Surveyed publishers rely on a variety of traffic and content data points in their efforts to acquire and retain subscribers amid the effects of AI search. The Digiday and Braze survey found that publishers are most interested in referral traffic data, regardless of whether referrals are AI-driven or not.

Eighty-four percent of publisher respondents said that referral traffic data from non-AI sources is important for their company’s overall subscription strategy, while 82% of respondents said the same of referral traffic data from AI sources. Subscription turnover data fell squarely in between the two types of referral traffic data at 83% of respondents.

Only 14% of surveyed publishers said known or logged-in traffic or content data points are important to their company’s overall subscription strategy, while 12% of respondents said the same of anonymous or not logged-in data. 

Ultimately, participating publishers ranked referral traffic data far above audience identification data in terms of what matters to their subscription strategies (84% vs. 14%), even as 90% of surveyed publishers said they use audience data to customize subscription conversion messaging, as shown in the survey data. This indicates a significant gap between the types of data publishers measure and rely on and what their actual tactics require.

This measurement versus subscriptions tactics gap points to a missed opportunity as AI reshapes discovery. While publishers understandably value knowing where traffic comes from and how readers behave once they arrive, knowing who those readers are — and building a direct, persistent relationship with them — can turn an otherwise fleeting visit into a source of actionable first-party data. 

As AI and traditional search make audience acquisition less predictable, publishers that prioritize identification alongside traffic source and behavior may be better positioned to convert more of those visits into lasting subscriber relationships.

While subscriptions are a major focus, publishers continue to support diversified revenue models, and their data usage shows this. The majority of publisher respondents use the traffic and content data points they’ve gathered primarily to customize subscription conversion messaging (90%) and for audience targeting and segmentation for advertising partners (87%). Slightly more than half of respondents (56%) use the data points for personalizing reader experiences, while 37% use them to reprioritize coverage areas and inform their editorial strategy. 

On the subscription side of their businesses, publishers can use behavioral signals to determine who is likely to subscribe and what message or offer to show them. On the advertising side, that same data can help publishers determine where consumers’ interests lie and package those audiences for advertisers.

“We use these data points to continuously optimize both our acquisition and retention activities,” Thrum said. “Conversion and content-performance data help us understand which campaigns and articles are most effective at driving subscriptions. Engagement metrics such as newsletter subscriptions, recency and frequency help us identify how actively customers interact with our products and enable us to tailor communications to different audience segments.”

“For example, highly engaged subscribers may receive different messaging than customers whose engagement has recently declined,” he added. “We also use metrics such as customer lifetime value to evaluate the long-term value of different customer segments and the effectiveness of our investments over time. Ultimately, these insights help us better understand customer behavior, create more relevant experiences, strengthen engagement and support both subscriber growth and retention.”

When Digiday spoke with Forbes svp of global sales Kyle Vinansky, he explained that Forbes creates audience segments to target specific demographic groups using data gathered from newsletter subscribers. 

“For everybody that engages on the site or across our platforms, we have user behavior habits and first-party data,” Vinansky said. “When you start getting into paid subscriptions or newsletters, you begin to get more demographic data. We’re storing all of that data in a centralized location to activate it as needed for different parts of the business. For instance, if we have a partner wanting to do a custom newsletter send, we can pick different segments of that audience to meet their objectives because we have the appropriate marketing opt-ins for all those different users.”

Quicho said most publishers already have the infrastructure in place to act on the data they’ve gathered to enhance their customer acquisition and retention efforts. That includes customer data platforms, warehouses and event tracking capabilities. What’s changing is how publishers put that data to work. 

“Behavioral signals from anonymous visits such as articles read, session depth and format preferences can feed propensity models before a reader ever identifies themselves,” Quicho said. “That allows publishers to tailor both the acquisition offer and its timing to actual intent rather than relying on a blanket prompt. The opportunity lies in evolving from data collection to data activation — turning that data into an experience the reader can actually see and feel.”

Canadian French-language publisher La Presse used Braze’s custom in-browser messages to create reader walls, or article pages that allow full access to content while providing a countdown-enabled reminder to create an account. La Presse doesn’t collect payment from readers or put its content behind paywalls, but the publication still wanted them to create accounts to measure content use. According to Braze, La Presse increased its conversion rate to 43% and acquired 139,000 new subscribers. 

“Behavioral triggers like reaching a paywall or reading a set number of free articles, combined with predictive scoring and intelligent channel and timing selection, can make an offer feel like a natural next step rather than an interruption,” Quicho explained. “Publishers can engage readers who are showing real intent while holding back from those who aren’t ready.”

When it comes to how publishers’ internal departments work together to use the data they’ve gathered, the majority of respondents (66%) said departments review data siloed and then collaborate later. Only 28% of surveyed publishers said departments cross-collaborate openly from the beginning.

Bild’s Thrum said sharing audience data and engagement insights across teams and publications is essential. Bild’s internal business teams collect subscriber feedback through customer surveys and share the insights with editorial teams. Externally, Bild collaborates with sibling publication Welt on best practices for the subscriptions business. “When teams work in silos, valuable customer insights can be lost,” Thrum said. “In my view, the biggest opportunity lies in creating a continuous feedback loop between audience data, customer insights, business decisions and editorial development to improve the overall subscriber experience and support long-term growth.”

As AI makes audience acquisition and retention more interconnected, breaking down silos between subscriptions and acquisition teams becomes increasingly important, according to Quicho. “Shared data makes cross-title growth possible without cannibalization,” said Quicho. “A reader can deepen their relationship with the brand they already value or discover a related title in the portfolio without every team messaging them independently.”

When data remains siloed, reader experiences become fragmented, Quicho added: “People receive duplicate or conflicting messages, teams lack a coordinated view of true lifetime value, and different parts of the organization compete for the same reader’s attention instead of building on one another’s signals.”

Surveyed publishers’ response to AI search is extending beyond their subscriber acquisition and retention efforts to include shifts to their overall engagement strategies. 

More than two-thirds of surveyed publishers (68%) said they are partnering with AI companies amid the effects of AI search. Two-thirds of surveyed publishers said that they are creating more answer engine optimization-friendly content (67%) and creating new engagement touchpoints like podcasts and community forums (67%). Only 21% of surveyed publishers said that they are seeing a decrease in traffic amid AI search.

These responses suggest publishers are looking for ways to adapt to AI search and mitigate its potential impact on audience acquisition, whether or not they’ve reported traffic declines. They’re doing so both by swimming with the current in terms of building relationships with AI companies and carving out new tributaries, such as creating more owned environments like podcasts and community forums.

USA Today Co., for example, is testing ways to reformat its content to make it easier for AI systems to access, understand and cite its journalism. The publisher is experimenting with formats including markdown pages, which are parallel, agent-readable versions of their sites, while also tracking which AI bots access its content and which formats are most frequently surfaced in AI search. 

The company has described the work as part of its broader effort to prepare for future licensing opportunities and improve the value of existing AI licensing relationships. “We recognize that we have to create and format content for humans and for machines,” said Mike Reed, chairman and CEO of USA Today Co., in a company earnings call on Aug. 6. “And while we see a change in search-driven behavior, we also see entirely new ways to license, distribute and monetize the trusted content we produce every day.” 

In general, publisher survey respondents were relatively optimistic about AI’s future impact on the publishing industry. 

Ninety-six percent of surveyed publishers said they expect AI to create new revenue streams, while 64% of publisher respondents said they expect AI companies to collaborate with them on licensing agreements. Notably, 87% of surveyed publishers said they will add new member-exclusive benefits as a result of AI, which will likely continue to fuel their subscriber acquisition and retention strategies.

The emerging licensing market may help explain surveyed publishers’ overall AI optimism. Digiday’s timeline of major publisher-AI deals in 2025 included agreements with OpenAI, Google, Microsoft, Amazon and Meta that increasingly covered the use of publisher content in search and AI-generated answers.

Many publishers remain cautious about how much value these arrangements will deliver, however. At Digiday’s Publishing Summit in March 2026, executives questioned whether investing was worthwhile when AI platforms generated little traffic and licensing revenue remained difficult to come by. “We have a whole team dedicated to partnerships and licensing, and we do make money off of them. But it’s more like, we want to protect our users and our data, and [our content],” one executive said.

Nevertheless, in May 2026, The Washington Post, Associated Press, People Inc. and USA Today Network were among 17 publishers that quietly signed six-figure AI licensing deals with data platform Snowflake. The agreements let enterprises query publishers’ paywalled or proprietary content inside Snowflake’s AI environment without exposing raw feeds or getting scraped for model training.

As AI search makes the path from discovery to a publisher’s website less predictable, converting the readers who do arrive into identifiable users becomes increasingly important, according to Quicho. “It’s the whole game,” Quicho said. “A reader who arrives, gets an answer and leaves unidentified represents a single interaction with no compounding value — no second touch, no additional data and no relationship. Identification turns a one-time visit into a long-term asset.”

Looking to the future, Quicho said publishers should prioritize capabilities that allow publishers to identify readers, predict their behavior and respond to signals quickly. Ultimately, the publishers who succeed over the next 12 to 18 months will be the ones that can act on what they already know, he said. 

“Activation speed is key,” said Quicho. “The publishers that pull ahead won’t necessarily have more data. Most subscription publishers already have plenty. They’ll be the ones that close the gap between collecting a signal and acting on it,” Quicho said.

Bild’s Thrum said that while it’s difficult to predict the long-term impact of AI search, a key success factor will be publishers’ ability to strengthen direct audience relationships whether through websites, apps, newsletters or other owned channels. 

“In my view, the publishers that succeed will be those that create trust, habit and ongoing engagement,” Thrum said. “Strong brands with highly engaged audiences will be best positioned to adapt to the changes brought by AI search.”

---

• Sixty percent of surveyed publishers said acquiring new subscribers is the primary focus of their subscription strategy.

• Surveyed publishers’ top new subscriber acquisition tactic is discounts (89%). Publishers also rely on member-exclusive newsletters, research or data access, podcasts and personalized content to acquire new subscribers and retain existing ones.
• Surveyed publishers increasingly use audience data to support their acquisition and retention strategies. Ninety percent of respondents said they are using traffic and content data to customize subscription conversion messaging.
• Data remains siloed at many organizations, with 66% of respondents saying teams review data separately before collaborating.
• Surveyed publishers are adapting their broader engagement strategies in light of AI search. Sixty-eight percent of respondents are partnering with AI companies, while 67% are creating more AEO-friendly content and new engagement touchpoints.
• Ninety-six percent of surveyed publishers expect AI to create new revenue streams, although the value of AI licensing remains uncertain.
• Surveyed publishers rank referral traffic data far above audience identification in what matters to subscription strategy (84% vs. 14%), even as 90% use audience data to customize subscription conversion messaging, a significant gap between what publishers measure and what their tactics require.
• As discovery becomes more fragmented, publishers need to capture audiences earlier, build direct relationships and turn behavioral signals into timely, relevant engagement.

---

About Braze

Braze is the leading customer engagement platform that empowers brands to Be Absolutely Engaging™. Braze helps brands deliver great customer experiences that drive value both for consumers and for their businesses. Built on a foundation of composable intelligence, BrazeAI™ allows marketers to combine and activate AI agents, models, and features at every touchpoint throughout the Braze Customer Engagement Platform for smarter, faster, and more meaningful customer engagement. From cross-channel messaging and journey orchestration to Al-powered decisioning and optimization, Braze enables companies to turn action into interaction through autonomous, 1:1 personalized experiences. The company has been consistently recognized as a Leader in marketing technology by industry analysts, and was named a G2 “Best of Marketing and Digital Advertising Software Product” in 2026. Braze was also named a 2026 Best Places to Work by Built In, a 2025 America’s Greenest Companies by Newsweek, and a 2025 Fortune Best Workplace in Technology™ by Great Place To Work®. The company is headquartered in New York with 15 offices across the Americas, EMEA, and APAC. Learn more at braze.com.